The Society To End Vegetation Explotation

The World's Oldest Plant Rights Organization

Responses to Our Charter

We've started to get responses to our charter. Maybe they'll interest or amuse some of you (they have been edited in some cases).

Mellanie Colt

Mellanie wrote to us after a post made to Fat Wallet critical of PETA.

December 1, 2005 9:47 PM

You must be a vegetable yourself! Are you so ignorant that you do NOT KNOW that meat eating animals consume far more vegetation to produce the same amount of food a vegetarian consumes? Let's see if these numbers makesense to you - 1 acre supports 44 vegetarians but only 1 cow.

I'm sorry, your comment in fatwallet was the most IGNORANT thing I've ever heard. You must be a cruel person to counter anti-cruelty efforts.

Meanie!

Wow, such eloquence. How could I possibly respond in the face of such logic....

My Response

Mellanie:

At 12/1/2005 09:47 PM, you wrote:
You must be a vegetable yourself! Are you so ignorant that you do NOT KNOW that meat eating animals consume far more vegetation to produce the same amount of food a vegetarian consumes? Let's see if these numbers make sense to you - 1 acre supports 44 vegetarians but only 1 cow.

Those numbers are irrelevant unless you state how many people that cow supports.

I'm sorry, your comment in fatwallet was the most IGNORANT thing I've ever heard. You must be a cruel person to counter anti-cruelty efforts.

Thank you for confirming my opinion of PETA people. I guess you've never heard that some people don't believe the Holocaust happened, that some people believe blacks were the product of people breeding with monkeys, that some people don't believe HIV causes AIDs and so on. Or are you just suffering from severe tunnel vision?

But do you not believe that plants are also living things? Do you not believe that people can be cruel to plants?

Meanie!

ROFL That's quite the closing line. Why didn't you just call me a "poopie head", too?

Thanks for the laughs,

Steve

Not content to give up, Mellanie graced us with another response.

December 2, 2005 1:01 AM

Mellanie:

At 12/1/2005 09:47 PM, you wrote:
You must be a vegetable yourself! Are you so ignorant that you do NOT KNOW that meat eating animals consume far more vegetation to produce the same amount of food a vegetarian consumes? Let's see if these numbers make sense to you - 1 acre supports 44 vegetarians but only 1 cow.

Those numbers are irrelevant unless you state how many people that cow supports.

Hmmm...lets see, not 44!

I'm sorry, your comment in fatwallet was the most IGNORANT thing I've ever heard. You must be a cruel person to counter anti-cruelty efforts.

Thank you for confirming my opinion of PETA people. I guess you've never heard that some people don't believe the Holocaust happened, that some people believe blacks were the product of people breeding with monkeys, that some people don't believe HIV causes AIDs and so on. Or are you just suffering from severe tunnel vision?

Please tell me that you are not one of those people! If so, perhaps you also believe that drastic weather changes have occured because of the hole the Apollo missions punched in the ozone. Give me a break! LOL!

But do you not believe that plants are also living things? Do you not believe that people can be cruel to plants?

Hmmm..... back to Biology 101....plants do not have pain receptors or a central nervous system...kind of like you...

Meanie!

ROFL That's quite the closing line. Why didn't you just call me a "poopie head", too?

Why bother - you already know you're one. You said it yourself.

My Response

Mellanie:

At 12/2/2005 01:01 AM, you wrote:

Mellanie:

At 12/1/2005 09:47 PM, you wrote:
You must be a vegetable yourself! Are you so ignorant that you do NOT KNOW that meat eating animals consume far more vegetation to produce the same amount of food a vegetarian consumes? Let's see if these numbers make sense to you - 1 acre supports 44 vegetarians but only 1 cow.

Those numbers are irrelevant unless you state how many people that cow supports.

Hmmm...lets see, not 44!

Well, as somebody with a college degree in math, I can tell you that 45 through infinity are not 44. Thanks for dodging the question, though.

I'm sorry, your comment in fatwallet was the most IGNORANT thing I've ever heard. You must be a cruel person to counter anti-cruelty efforts.

Thank you for confirming my opinion of PETA people. I guess you've never heard that some people don't believe the Holocaust happened, that some people believe blacks were the product of people breeding with monkeys, that some people don't believe HIV causes AIDs and so on. Or are you just suffering from severe tunnel vision?

Please tell me that you are not one of those people! If so, perhaps you also believe that drastic weather changes have occured because of the hole the Apollo missions punched in the ozone. Give me a break! LOL!

Considering that I was mentioning "those people" in the context of "things that were more IGNORANT than my comments", wouldn't most intelligent people assume that I'm not one of them? But I guess that I just answered my own question.

But do you not believe that plants are also living things? Do you not believe that people can be cruel to plants?

Hmmm..... back to Biology 101....plants do not have pain receptors or a central nervous system...kind of like you...

Ooh, another good one. Have you considered a career as an insult comic?

However, have you heard of studies that indicate that plants can communicate and feel pain? Either you don't believe them or you don't care.

Meanie!

ROFL That's quite the closing line. Why didn't you just call me a "poopie head", too?

Why bother - you already know you're one. You said it yourself.

Actually, I asked you a question. Perhaps your education isn't sufficient to distinguish between an interrogative and a declarative statement, but here's a clue — my asking why you didn't call me something is not an indication that I think I am that thing.

But thanks for playing. I created a new page just for you. Enjoy your fame!

Steve



Want to join? E-mail us at stevem@svpocketpc.com.
You are visitor # according to Web Counter.
Last updated December 2, 2005